The expensive part of consultants is rarely the hourly rate

I am a consultant myself, so take this with an appropriate pinch of salt. But I have also sat on the buying side, and in my experience it is rarely the hourly rate that makes a consultancy engagement expensive. It is everything that happens before and after the contract.

What the National Audit Office found

When the Swedish National Audit Office reviewed how government agencies buy consultancy services, it concluded that their use was generally not well founded and that agencies lacked control over it. Decisions to hire consultants were not always based on a needs analysis, and the work was rarely evaluated. The state buys consultancy services worth around SEK 16 billion a year, so this is not small change.

The same pattern appears locally. When auditors reviewed two municipal companies in Jönköping, one of their objections was the lack of documented needs analyses.

My own principle is simple. Knowledge that matters to the business should be built in-house. Consultants should be used for what they are genuinely good at: specialist expertise, experience from many other organisations and the energy to drive something forward for a period. And every assignment should have knowledge transfer built in. I usually say that I have succeeded when the organisation knows more when I leave than when I arrived. If they need me again for the same thing, I have not done my job.

Where the money actually goes

The assignment is unclear from the start. If the buyer cannot say what should be finished and by when, the consultant fills the gap. Usually in good faith, but at your expense.

Nobody owns the assignment internally. A consultant without a clear counterpart becomes an extra team member nobody manages. The hours keep coming, but nobody checks what they lead to.

The knowledge walks out the door. When the assignment ends, the consultant has learned the most. If you do not plan for handover, you buy the same knowledge again next time.

What I want my own clients to do

  1. Write down what should be finished, not just which skills you need.
  2. Appoint an internal owner with the time and mandate to steer the assignment.
  3. Decide how you will evaluate it before it starts, and then do it.

It may sound as if I am shooting myself in the foot. I am not. The best assignments I have had all had a client who knew what she wanted.

A question for your next leadership meeting

How many of our ongoing consultancy assignments have a written description of what should be finished?

Sources: Government communication 2018/19:24 on the audit report on consultancy purchasing (Swedish) · Parliamentary finance committee report 2018/19:FiU31 (Swedish) · Jönköping municipality, audit of consultant use in Elmia AB and Jönköping Energi AB (Swedish)

What does it look like in your organisation?

Take the consultant governance assessment to see where you stand, or book 30 minutes with me for an independent view of how you buy consultancy.