Insight · Governance and accountability
Accountability exists on paper. It gets lost in the gaps
If you ask a manager what she is responsible for, you almost always get a clear answer. If you ask who is responsible for what lies between two managers' areas, the room goes quiet. That is where most of the problems I come across begin.
Auditors see it, the organisation does not
When auditors in Sollefteå, a Swedish municipality, followed up an earlier review, they had found responsibilities within the organisation to be unclear and recommended clarifying them between politicians and officials. The follow-up showed that the municipality did not share the auditors' view. That is a pattern I recognise. From the inside, responsibilities look clear, because each part knows what it does itself. It is from the outside that you see the gaps.
Auditors in Vilhelmina put the consequence briefly: unclear division of responsibility makes it hard to hold anyone to account when the work is not carried out as intended. Nobody has done anything wrong, but nobody can be held responsible either.
Four seams where accountability tends to disappear
Between strategy and finance. The strategy says one thing, the budget another. Nobody owns the question of how they fit together.
Between finance and operations. Finance follows up the money, operations follow up quality. Nobody follows up what the money actually achieves.
Between operations and delivery. The decision is made in one part of the organisation and has to be carried out in another. The handover becomes an email.
Between your organisation and suppliers. The contract describes the supplier's responsibilities, but not who on your side should steer them.
How to find the gaps
- Follow a real case from start to finish and note every time it changes owner. Where it becomes unclear, you have a seam.
- Ask several managers the same question: who is responsible for making sure this gets done? If you get different answers, you have found a gap.
- Give every seam an owner. Not a coordination group, but one person with the mandate to make decisions when needed.
My basic view is that delivery happens in the line, with clear accountability. That applies to what lies between the lines too.
A question for your next leadership meeting
Which issue in our organisation sits between two managers' areas of responsibility, and who owns it today?
Sources: Sollefteå municipality, follow-up of earlier audits (Swedish) · Vilhelmina municipality, audit of managers' responsibilities (Swedish)
Next step
What does it look like in your organisation?
Take the organisational accountability assessment to see where your gaps are, or book 30 minutes with me about how responsibilities are divided.