Insight · Organisation
A new org chart does not change how people work
I have been through many reorganisations, both as a manager and as a consultant. The most common disappointment is not that the new structure is wrong. It is that everything works more or less as before, just with new boxes on the chart.
The effects are often smaller than expected
The Swedish Agency for Public Management has analysed several occasions when the government merged agencies. In a consultation response, it summed up that it had identified a number of positive effects, but that they were limited and often hard to realise. That is a sober conclusion from an agency that has seen many reorganisations up close.
I think the same applies in municipalities and companies. A reorganisation is a powerful tool, but it is also expensive. It takes time, energy and focus away from the business for a long time.
My basic view is that an organisation, however it is drawn, exists to deliver. And delivery happens in the line, with clear accountability. What I often see instead is staff functions being built up to provide control and reporting. The line gets tied up with spreadsheets and monthly reports to a staff unit that lives on creating a control it can never really achieve, because it is not part of the delivery itself. The result is more administration and less delivery.
Why it rarely turns out as planned
The problem was not in the structure. If two departments do not work well together, it is tempting to merge them. But if the cause is unclear goals, weak processes or the wrong leadership, the problem moves into the new organisation too.
Ways of working do not move automatically. People keep doing what they have always done, with the same colleagues and the same routines, until someone actively changes it.
Follow-up is missing. Once the new organisation is in place, leadership moves on to the next issue. Nobody checks whether things got better.
Before you redraw the chart
- Describe the problem without mentioning the organisation. What is not working today, for whom, and how does it show?
- Test whether it can be solved without reorganising. Often clearer responsibilities, a new process or a different style of leadership is enough.
- If you do reorganise, decide in advance how you will know it worked, and follow it up after a year.
A question for your next leadership meeting
Which problem was our last reorganisation meant to solve, and can we show that it is solved?
Sources: Swedish Agency for Public Management, consultation response on agency mergers (Swedish)
Next step
What does it look like in your organisation?
Take the organisational change assessment to see where you stand, or book 30 minutes with me before you decide on the next reorganisation.