A steering committee that only receives reports steers nothing

I have sat on and worked with many steering committees. The most common format is a meeting where the project manager goes through a status report, everyone nods and the meeting ends ten minutes early. It feels efficient. But nobody has steered anything.

The accountability is real, even when the steering is not

It shows most clearly when something goes wrong. After the serious problems with the rollout of the Millennium health record system in Västra Götaland, and sharp criticism from an external review, Swedish public television SVT reported that members of the steering group and the programme director had to leave their roles. That shows something important: a steering committee carries the responsibility, whether or not it has actually steered.

Auditors in Herrljunga pointed to a related weakness in the municipality's decision-making. The minutes often lacked information about responsibilities and timelines. The same applies to many steering committees. Decisions are vague, and so they cannot be followed up.

Signs your steering committee is not steering

The meeting is about what has happened, not what needs deciding. The agenda is a status report, not a list of decisions.

Decision points slip. When a choice has to be made, old questions are reopened and the decision is pushed to the next meeting.

Nobody challenges the project manager. The committee trusts the picture it is given and rarely asks the uncomfortable questions.

There is no decision log. Six months on, nobody can see what the committee actually decided.

How to make the committee steer

  1. Build the agenda around decisions. Every meeting should have at least one decision to make, otherwise no meeting is needed.
  2. Ask for options. The project manager should present choices with consequences, not just a recommendation.
  3. Keep a decision log and review it at the start of every meeting.
  4. Decide in advance when the project will be reconsidered, for example at a certain cost increase or delay.

A question for your next leadership meeting

Which decision did our steering committee make at its last meeting, and how will we follow it up?

Sources: SVT on the changes to the Millennium steering group (Swedish) · Herrljunga municipality, audit of implementation of council decisions (Swedish)

What does it look like in your organisation?

Take the steering committee assessment to see whether yours actually steers, or book 30 minutes with me about changing how it works.