The most dangerous decision paper is the one with only one option

The most expensive decisions I have seen were not stupid when they were made. They were reasonable given what was on the table. It was the decision paper that was thin, and nobody noticed until it was too late.

Even central government has this problem

The Swedish National Audit Office has pointed to the same issue year after year. In its 2019 annual report, the auditors general wrote that they had seen cases where impact assessments, planning and scenarios were inadequate or misleading. In a review of how infrastructure options were assessed, they found weaknesses in both planning and decision papers, meaning cheaper alternatives to large and costly investments risked never being considered. Five years later, the annual report again highlighted weaknesses in the material presented to parliament.

If it happens with the resources central government has for analysis, it happens in a municipality, a company or a department too.

I have seen this many times in large national healthcare digitalisation projects. People lock onto one option early, often a single large system, and nothing else is ever seriously tested. The decision paper is not thorough enough, but nobody wants to be the one who questions it. The Millennium health record system in Västra Götaland is the clearest example. It went live in November 2024 and was halted after three days because patient safety could not be guaranteed. According to the business daily EFN, SEK 3.7 billion had already been spent when a coordination group recommended scrapping the project, and the region then had to pay the supplier SEK 657 million to exit the contract. Instead, the region chose a modular approach. That option could have been on the table from the start.

Three signs of a thin decision paper

There is only one option. A paper that presents one solution and asks whether you want it or not is really an order form. Leadership has nothing to choose between.

Consequences are described with adjectives. “Significant effects”, “some risk”, “improved service”. You cannot follow up an adjective.

Nobody has written down how you will know if it worked. Without a description of what will be measured and when, the decision will never be evaluated.

What leadership can ask for

I usually suggest a simple rule: no major decision without at least two real options, one of which is to do nothing. For each option, state what it costs, what it delivers, which risks remain and who owns them.

It sounds obvious, but it changes the dynamic in the room. The question shifts from “shall we say yes?” to “which of these is best for us?”. And whoever prepared the paper has to think through what would otherwise have stayed unsaid.

A question for your next leadership meeting

Which of our recent major decisions did we make without seeing a single real alternative?

Sources: Swedish National Audit Office, annual report 2019 (Swedish) · Parliamentary committee report on the 2024 annual audit report (Swedish) · EFN on the costs of Millennium (Swedish) · Läkartidningen on ending Millennium (Swedish)

What does it look like in your organisation?

Take the decision material assessment to see how well your papers hold up, or book 30 minutes with me ahead of a decision that feels difficult.