Insight · Property
The maintenance backlog nobody can put a number on
If you read audit reports on municipal property maintenance in Sweden, one sentence keeps coming back. It is not possible to say how big the maintenance backlog is. That sounds like a technical detail. It actually means leadership is making decisions about very large assets without knowing what it is pushing into the future.
Auditors keep finding the same gap
In Härryda, the auditors noted that there was no analysis of the municipality's total maintenance backlog. In Bromölla, they wrote that the size of the backlog could not be stated with any precision because the maintenance plans were too uncertain. In Nacka, there were no calculations of how large it was. Three municipalities, three audits, one conclusion.
I think that tells us something. It is rarely the case that nobody knows maintenance is falling behind. Anyone who walks through a school or a care home can see it. What is missing is someone who has turned it into something a board or committee can actually decide on.
I have seen what it looks like when it goes too far. In one municipality, emergency repairs had effectively replaced planned maintenance. There was a maintenance plan, but year after year the money went to whatever had already broken. Every emergency repair cost many times more than if it had been planned, and in the end it was the residents who paid, both in taxes and in worse buildings.
Why the number is missing
I see three explanations, and none of them is about people being careless.
The plan and the budget live in different worlds. The maintenance plan is a long list of actions, years and amounts. The budget is set somewhere else, where the question is how much money the property department gets. Nobody translates between the two.
Waiting pays off in the short term. Deferred maintenance does not show up in this year's result. The bill arrives later, as breakdowns, closed buildings and bigger investments.
Everything ends up in the same column. When operations, planned maintenance, emergency repairs and investment are reported together, you cannot tell whether maintenance is sufficient or whether you are just fixing what breaks.
I recognise the pattern from my years as a CIO. Technical debt in IT systems behaves exactly the same way. It is invisible in the budget until something fails, and by then it always costs more than if you had dealt with it in time.
What I would do first
- Spot-check the plan. Pick ten buildings and compare the maintenance plan with what an inspection actually shows. The gap tells you more about the quality of the plan than any summary.
- Turn the list into three numbers. What does it cost to fix what is overdue today? What does it cost if we wait three years? Which buildings could put operations at risk?
- Make a funded multi-year decision. Not a budget line that gets renegotiated every autumn, but a decision with an owner, a plan and an annual report back.
A question for your next leadership meeting
If we had to close a building tomorrow because of neglected maintenance, do we know which one it would be?
If the answer takes a while, you have the same gap the auditors keep finding elsewhere. Nothing to be ashamed of, but a clear sign that maintenance needs to become a leadership issue.
Sources: Härryda municipality, audit of property maintenance (Swedish) · Bromölla municipality, audit report on property maintenance (Swedish) · Nacka municipality, report 5/2019 on maintenance (Swedish)
Next step
What does it look like in your organisation?
Take the maintenance backlog assessment to see where you stand, or book 30 minutes with me if you want an independent view of your maintenance plan.