Runaway projects are almost never stopped. They should be

The hardest decision in a project is not starting it. It is stopping it when circumstances have changed. I have seen many projects carry on long after everyone in the room knew they should have been halted.

The numbers are clear

When the Swedish National Audit Office reviewed national infrastructure planning in 2021, the estimated cost of projects that appeared in two consecutive plans had risen by a total of SEK 58 billion. That was an average of 39 per cent per project in just four years. The increases occurred mainly during planning, not construction. Even so, one of the review's conclusions was that projects are rarely stopped despite large cost increases.

This is not a new pattern. As early as 2010, the auditors showed that large road investments ended up 8 to 18 per cent more expensive than the first planned cost, and that reporting concealed some of the increases.

The clearest examples I have seen are in large healthcare IT programmes. So much work and money has gone in that the feeling becomes that it has to move forward, whatever happens. Meanwhile, the clinical staff who are supposed to use the system can see that it is unusable, and in some cases downright dangerous. At that point prestige and ego take over. Nobody wants to be the one who says it does not work, and the project rolls on long after it should have been stopped.

Why nobody hits the brakes

What has been spent feels lost. The more money that has gone in, the harder it is to say stop. That is human, but economically wrong. The only thing that matters is whether the remaining money is worth what is still to be gained.

Nobody decided in advance when to reconsider. Without a threshold that triggers a new decision, the project drifts on, one change at a time.

The person reporting has an interest. The project manager wants to succeed and tends to see problems as temporary. That is not dishonest, but it makes leadership's picture too rosy.

Build in the right to stop

What I suggest is giving every major project a clear review threshold from the start. If the cost rises by more than, say, 15 per cent, or the schedule slips by more than six months, the project goes back to leadership as a new decision, with cancelling as one of the options.

That makes things much easier for everyone. The project manager does not have to feel she has failed, and leadership avoids having to decide at a point where it already feels too late.

A question for your next leadership meeting

Which of our current projects would we start today, knowing what we know now?

If the answer is none of them, or you are not sure, it is time for a review.

Sources: Swedish National Audit Office, review of cost control in infrastructure planning, 2021 (Swedish) · Parliamentary transport committee report on the audit of large road investments, RiR 2010:25 (Swedish)

What does it look like in your organisation?

Take the project cost overrun assessment to see where your risks are, or book 30 minutes with me about a project that worries you.